Home › Podcasts › Land Titles Jurisprudence
Land Titles Jurisprudence · Podcast Episode 8 · 21:34
Can You Sell Free Patent Land Within 5 Years? Free Patent vs. Homestead
Is a sale of free patent or homestead land within five years void, and what changed in 2019?
In General Santos City, a company paid ₱14 million as down payment for lots whose patents were less than five years old. Atty. Jeric Dave Gallardo and Sweet Zel Grace Porras walk through three Supreme Court decisions on Sec. 118 of the Public Land Act, a conditional sale, a homestead sold in 1970 without the Secretary’s approval and a “quitclaim”, plus a twist: R.A. No. 11231 (2019), the Agricultural Free Patent Reform Act.
Four cases, four answers
Same question. Different facts. Different results.
The rule
Under Sec. 118 of the Public Land Act, land acquired under a free patent or homestead may not be alienated or encumbered, except in favor of the Government, from the approval of the application until five years after the patent is issued, and the Court has held a sale within that period void, whether it is called a conditional sale or a quitclaim.
For a homestead, Sec. 118 also requires the Secretary’s approval of a sale made after five years and before twenty-five years from the title, but Alfredo vs. Borras held that its absence does not by itself make the sale void. R.A. No. 11231 (2019) lifted the restrictions of Secs. 118, 119 and 121 for agricultural free patents issued under Sec. 44 of C.A. No. 141, retroactively, though it keeps the Sec. 119 right of redemption for earlier transactions made in good faith; its words do not mention homesteads. In 2021, in Heirs of Bagaygay vs. Heirs of Paciente, the Court held void a 1956 homestead sale executed within the five years; it mentioned R.A. No. 11231 only in a footnote and did not discuss whether the law reaches homesteads.
Recap
- Sec. 118 bars the sale or encumbrance of land from a free patent or homestead, except in favor of the Government, from the approval of the application until five years after the patent is issued.
- Whether it is called a conditional sale or a “quitclaim”, a conveyance within the five years is still a conveyance, and void; after the five years, a homestead sale is not void just because the Secretary did not approve it.
- Since 2019, under R.A. No. 11231, agricultural free patents issued under Sec. 44 no longer carry this restriction; homesteads are not in the law’s words.
Bar tip
Asked whether a sale of land from a patent is valid, ask three questions: what kind of patent is it (a homestead, an agricultural free patent, or a residential free patent under R.A. No. 10023), when was it issued and when was the land sold, and has a law removed the restriction? In the answer, use R.A. No. 11231’s own words: it covers agricultural free patents issued under Sec. 44 of C.A. No. 141.
The law
Public Land Act (C.A. No. 141), Secs. 118 and 119, and the Agricultural Free Patent Reform Act (R.A. No. 11231)
“Except in favor of the Government or any of its branches, units, or institutions, lands acquired under free patent or homestead provisions shall not be subject to encumbrance or alienation from the date of the approval of the application and for a term of five years from and after the date of issuance of the patent or grant, nor shall they become liable to the satisfaction of any debt contracted prior to the expiration of said period, but the improvements or crops on the land may be mortgaged or pledged to qualified persons, associations, or corporations.”C.A. No. 141, Sec. 118, first paragraph (as amended by C.A. No. 456, June 8, 1939)
“No alienation, transfer, or conveyance of any homestead after five years and before twenty-five years after issuance of title shall be valid without the approval of the Secretary of Agriculture and Commerce, which approval shall not be denied except on constitutional and legal grounds.”C.A. No. 141, Sec. 118, second paragraph (as amended by C.A. No. 456)
“Every conveyance of land acquired under the free patent or homestead provisions, when proper, shall be subject to repurchase by the applicant, his widow, or legal heirs, within a period of five years from the date of the conveyance.”C.A. No. 141, Sec. 119
“Agricultural public lands alienated or disposed in favor of qualified public land applicants under Section 44 of Commonwealth Act No. 141, as amended, shall not be subject to restrictions imposed under Sections 118, 119 and 121 thereof regarding acquisitions, encumbrances, conveyances, transfers, or dispositions. Agricultural free patent shall now be considered as title in fee simple and shall not be subject to any restriction on encumbrance or alienation.”R.A. No. 11231 (approved February 22, 2019), Sec. 3
“This Act shall have retroactive effect and any restriction regarding acquisitions, encumbrances, conveyances, transfers, or dispositions imposed on agricultural free patents issued under Section 44 of Commonwealth Act No. 141, as amended, before the effectivity of this Act shall be removed and are hereby immediately lifted: Provided, That nothing in this Act shall affect the right of redemption under Section 119 of Commonwealth Act No. 141, as amended, for transactions made in good faith prior to the effectivity of this Act.”R.A. No. 11231, Sec. 4
C.A. No. 141, Public Land Act (LawPhil) · C.A. No. 456 (LawPhil) · R.A. No. 11231 (LawPhil) · R.A. No. 10023 (LawPhil)
Chapters
- 0:00Cold open: can you sell land from a free patent?
- 1:50Can you sell free patent land? C.A. No. 141, Sec. 118 (free patent and homestead)
- 4:18Case 1: Filinvest Land vs. Backy (a conditional sale, General Santos, 2012)
- 8:20Case 2: Alfredo vs. Borras (a homestead, no approval from the Secretary, 2003)
- 12:02Case 3: Flores vs. Bagaoisan (a “quitclaim”, Ilocos Norte, 2010)
- 15:12The twist: R.A. No. 11231 (Agricultural Free Patent Reform Act, 2019)
- 18:33How do they fit together? Three questions on free patents and homesteads
- 19:48Recap and bar tip
Cases cited
Each card opens the full text of the decision, or our case digest where we have written one.
Next episode
The homestead was sold: can the family still buy it back?
All 8 episodes of Land Titles Jurisprudence →
Related episode
